In Paris for the exhibition ‘Manet/Degas’ at the Musée d’Orsay, which examines both the similarities and differences between the two artists who both played a pivotal role in the new painting styles of the 1860s – 1880s.
They had many similar experiences; both being involved in the Franco-Prussian War of 1870 – 71 and both frequenting the same places in Paris with mutual friends. However, whilst Degas exhibited with the Impressionists, Manet refused to do so, despite similarities in their subject matter.
Despite their differences there was a mutual admiration and respect. After Manet died in 1883, one of his heirs cut up one of the versions of ‘The Execution of Maximilian’ to sell the parts separately; however, Degas bought the fragments in order to reassemble the painting and then went on to collect many more of Manet’s works.
Edgar Degas ‘Woman on a Terrace’ (1857)
Edouard Manet ‘Olympia’ (1863)
Edouard Manet ‘The Execution of Maximilian’ (1867 – 68)
Edouard Manet ‘Portrait of Emile Zola’ (1868)
Edouard Manet ‘The Balcony’ (1868 – 69)
Edouard Manet ‘Berthe Morisot with Bouquet of Violets’ (1872)
Edgar Degas ‘A Cotton Office in New Orleans’ (1873)
Edgar Degas ‘In a Café (L’Absinthe)’ (1875 – 76)
Edgar Degas ‘The Tub’ (1886)
Paul Gauguin ‘Olympia (after Manet)’
Both Edouard Manet and Edgar Degas, particularly the latter, also feature in the Musée d’Orsay’s other current exhibition, ‘Pastels from Millet to Redon’.
Pastel is a technique that brings together both line and colour without being either drawing or painting. Pastels are versatile, enabling blended shading and hatching as well as textured finishes and bright colouring.
Pastel was first used in the sixteenth century, notably by Leonardo da Vinci, but underwent a resurgence in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. Jean-François Millet often used pastel in his depictions of rural life. Edgar Degas became particularly skilled in the use of pastels, placing complementary and contrasting hues side by side to produce rich tapestries of colour. Odilon Redon was another artist who used pastels to produce extremely colourful effects.
Jean-François Millet ‘The Woman at the Well’ (c.1866 – 68)
Édouard Manet ‘Portrait of Irma Brunner’ (1880 – 82)
Edgar Degas ‘Seated Dancer’ (1881 – 83)
Edgar Degas ‘Dancers’ (1884 – 85)
Lucien Levy-Dhurmer ‘Woman with a Medallion’ (1896)
Edgar Degas ‘At the Milliner’s’ (c.1905 – 10)
Odilon Redon ‘Buddha’ (c.1906 – 07)